Lord Falconer and Revolving Doors – “Recall should protect the public, not punish instability.”
The argument for a distinct focus on those caught in the ‘revolving door’ and a whole system approach to diversion as a test case for the devolution agenda, co-written by Revolving Doors CEO, Pavan Dhaliwal and Lord Falconer. Originally published in LabourList.
There are around 85,000 people in prison in England and Wales. Over 12,000 of them are people who had been released from prison in accordance with the terms of their sentence but have been recalled to prison for a breach of the conditions on which they were released.
Some of those recalled have rightly been returned to prison because they have committed another serious offence, or because their behaviour demonstrates that they cannot safely be managed in the community. But the majority of people recalled to prison do not fall into that category. Only 22% have committed a further offence. Of the 78% who have not committed a further offence, many have been recalled for failing to comply with licence conditions, despite often posing little or no direct risk to the public.
“Sometimes, instead of recall, you just need more support,” said one Revolving Doors member with lived experience of recall.
A missed appointment or a change of address can be treated as non-compliance. But these breaches often arise amid homelessness, insecure accommodation, poor mental health, addiction, debt and fractured support networks. Those pressures can make it difficult to meet licence conditions even when someone is trying to rebuild their life.
Recall can then disrupt the very things that make a successful return to the community possible: treatment, housing, employment and family relationships. People can become caught in a cycle of “release, recall, release, recall”, with prison interrupting progress without resolving the problems that led to the breach.
“If you’re clean and released from prison into an HMO rife with drugs, do you stay and risk relapsing, or leave and risk being recalled for breaching your licence conditions?” asked another Revolving Doors member. “People are being recalled simply for trying to protect their recovery.”
We need a problem-solving approach that asks what has happened, what risk it presents and what response will best protect the public. Where someone misses appointments because they are homeless, relapses into substance use or disengages as their mental health deteriorates, the first response should be to address the underlying problem wherever that can be done safely.
This is not a call to remove recall or to discount risk. It is a call to use it proportionately, with the right support available to probation staff and people under supervision.
That distinction is not always straightforward. Probation officers must make difficult judgments about whether a breach signals a heightened risk or a crisis that can be managed in the community. They need the confidence, training and organisational support to make those judgments, especially in a relatively inexperienced workforce working under significant pressure.
The combination of prison overcrowding, rising recall numbers and evidence that recall can undermine rehabilitation means the current approach requires reform. Policy should continue to support recall where there is a significant risk of harm to the public or a specific individual.
The most immediately useful reform would be an early review of every existing recall, with a duty to explain why continued custody is still necessary. This matters particularly under the current system. The April 2026 policy framework records that most adults serving standard determinate sentences now receive a 56-day fixed-term recall. It also expressly permits release before the fixed term ends where probation assesses release as safe and submits the required report. Making that route prompt and routine could reduce unnecessary detention without indiscriminate release.
There is also a strong case for preventing recall from destroying the arrangements that were keeping someone stable. Where possible, preserve accommodation, employment and treatment during a recall. Otherwise, a person can emerge with fewer protective factors than before. Recall will often interrupt community psychiatric programmes.
And a specific analysis should be undertaken in relation to women who have been recalled. The prisons inspectorate found that at Foston Hall about 60% of women leaving short fixed-term recalls were homeless, compared with 20% of the general population leaving that prison (Revolving Doors and Lord Falconer have proposed an urgent analysis of what is different for women offenders).
Alongside that, it should;
- Introduce a presumption against recall for minor and technical breaches where risk remains manageable.
- Require a recorded explanation of why community-based responses are insufficient before recall is authorised.
- Ensure that breaches linked to homelessness, addiction, mental ill-health or other forms of multiple disadvantage trigger a support response before a custodial response wherever possible.
- Embed recall decisions in local, multi-agency approaches that can quickly mobilise housing, treatment, peer support and crisis services to stabilise people in the community.
There is already useful work to build on. Greater Manchester’s Whole System Approach to Diversion, the West Midlands’ Offending to Recovery programme and work in Nottingham on Operation Brandberg show different ways of bringing services together around people whose needs cross the boundaries between criminal justice, housing, health and treatment. They are not identical models. Their shared principle is that no single service can solve a problem that spans the whole system.
This is also a practical case for devolution. Local leaders are better placed to bring local services together and respond to local needs. But that coordination needs to sit alongside a clear national framework, so probation staff can draw on local support and have confidence that a proportionate, community-based response is recognised as a legitimate way to manage risk.
At its heart, reform should focus recall on people who pose a genuine risk of harm, while providing meaningful support where a breach reflects unmet need rather than escalating dangerousness. The goal is not simply to reduce the number of people in prison. It is to make communities safer by breaking the cycle of crisis and crime.
The person presenting the greatest risk should be recalled. Where risk can be safely managed, a person’s crisis should prompt help, not an automatic return to custody.
ENDS
Notes to the editor:
Lord Falconer is a Labour Peer and was Lord Chancellor from 2003-7
Originally published in LabourList.
Revolving Doors are experts providing solutions for those trapped in the ‘revolving door’ of crisis and crime. Home – Revolving Doors
Over the course of two years our arguments on prevention and diversion have gained real ground – and are stronger than ever. Beyond the Cycle #2: Turning green shoots into systemic change – Revolving Doors
We are experts in diversion and have long called for a Whole System Approach:
- One joined-up team, one plan: police, probation, courts, NHS, housing and drug/alcohol services working as a single system around the person.
- Fast routes to the basics: housing + treatment + mental health support delivered quickly, before crisis becomes crime.
- Problem-solving justice: courts and probation linked into local services, so supervision comes with real help and clear consequences.
- Trusted support: consistent, trauma-informed practitioners plus peer mentors to keep people engaged and on track.
- Clear grip and accountability: shared data, shared outcomes, and someone locally responsible for delivery—not a handover between agencies.
Revolving Doors is a national charity working to break the cycle of crisis and crime. We advocate for a system that addresses the drivers of contact with the criminal justice system, including trauma, poverty and discrimination. We bring independent research, policy expertise and lived experience together to champion long-term solutions for justice reform.
To arrange an interview with Antonia May – Director of Communications and Campaigns of Revolving Doors please email Antonia.cross@revolving-doors.org.uk or call 07803 530891